Tuesday, June 28, 2011

CIWF wins award.......Do they deserve it?


CIWF wins award for Nocton campaign

COMPASSION  in World Farming has won an ethical award for its campaign to halt the proposed Nocton mega dairy, in Lincolnshire.
The animal welfare charity picked up the Campaigner of the Year award in the Observer Ethical Awards 2011 on Thursday at London’s Victoria & Albert museum.
It was honoured for its ‘Cows Belong in Fields’ campaign, sparked by Nocton Dairies’ plans for an 8,100-cow dairy unit last year.
Nocton withdrew its application earlier this year. At the time it said the sole reason was the refusal of the Environment Agency to lift its objections made on the basis of the risk of groundwater pollution.
But CIWF claimed ‘the huge intensity of public opposition’ and  the work of organisations like itself were also factors.
The award was accepted by leading CIWF officials and celebrity supporters Bill Oddie and vet Marc Abrahams (celebrity vet).
CIWF prevailed over other high profile shortlisted candidates such as Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall and 38 Degrees, which also campaigned against the Nocton proposal.
CIWF’s Nocton Campaign Manager, Pat Thomas, said the ongoing campaign ‘stretches beyond Nocton, at a time when the spectre of the factory-farming threatens to undermine the UK dairy industry’.
“We are celebrating both the win and the public momentum behind it that says unambiguously that factory farming is cruel, unsustainable and unacceptable.”
CIWF shared the award with local campaigners, including CAFFO (Campaign Against Factory Farming Operations)
“Defeating the mega-dairy took genuine teamwork and we were happy to provide local support and are grateful for the support that we received in return from local people and groups, particularly CAFFO. It was clear to us from the beginning that the proprietors of Nocton Dairies had dangerously underestimated the knowledge and persistence of local residents and the weight of public pressure,” she said.
The charity said it ‘continues its fight against mega-dairies in the UK’ and said it recently submitted an objection to the proposed 1,000-cow ‘mega-dairy’ in Powys, Wales.
CIWF’s award follows hot on the heels of a Chartered Institute of Public Relations excellence award for the World Society for the Protection Animals’ ‘Not in my Cuppa’ campaign, also opposing the Nocton project.
CIWF’s award was announced the day after the Women’s Institute decided not to vote on a resolution to oppose large scale farms. 

Readers' comments (2)

  • Er.Did the application not get withdrawn because the EA said there was an unacceptable risk? Well done Compassion in World farming and all that for what I am sure was a very good and well executed camapign and for that reason alone I am sure you deserve your accolade, but can you explain exactly how your campaign was a 'factor'? Are you suggesting that you influenced the techncial team of scientists in a government agency? Interesting that others are also spotting this tendency among certain donation-funded campaign groups to claim all the credit. http://www.ipaquotas.com/QUOTANEWS.htm
    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment
  • The way I remember the recent campaign and the results of the planning objections serve me to recall that the major reason why the application failed was owing to the EAs concerns over potential contamination of the local acquifier. The Planning authorities also indicated that "they were minded" to turn the application down for several other reasons none associated with welfare of animals nor on compassionate grounds. Whilst I accept the the support of National bodies were important, they were not instrumental in determining the result. I would have awarded the Ethical accolade to the good people of Nocton, Metheringham, Branston etc etc who stopped this Super dairy with first-class reasoning and a real sense of community.........Let's not rewrite history by passing out accolades to the wrong organisations..........
    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Enhanced by Zemanta

No comments:

Post a Comment